Challenging a Will for Undue Influence in Ontario

Challenging a will for undue influence means arguing that the document reflects someone else’s wishes rather than the deceased’s. The claim is that pressure was applied to the point where the person making the will was no longer acting freely.

Families often suspect this after seeing a long-standing plan rewritten late in life to favour one relative, a new partner or a caregiver. Suspicion is common and understandable. Establishing undue influence is a more specific exercise, and this article explains what it involves.

What undue influence means in Ontario

Undue influence is coercion. The pressure has to be strong enough that the person making the will was effectively acting on someone else’s wishes instead of their own.

The line between influence and coercion matters, because a good deal of ordinary family behaviour falls on the acceptable side of it. A relative can ask, argue, help, or care for an ageing parent and hope to be remembered for it, and the parent remains free to favour them. What changes the analysis is pressure that removes the person’s freedom to decide: threats, isolation from other family, or control over the circumstances of daily life.

Undue influence is also distinct from capacity. A capacity challenge says the person did not understand what they were doing; an undue influence challenge says they understood but were coerced. Our article on challenging a will for lack of testamentary capacity covers the other ground, and the two are sometimes raised together.

Circumstances that often prompt a challenge

Certain patterns come up repeatedly in these cases. None of them establishes undue influence on its own, and each has an innocent explanation in many families.

  • A significant change to a settled estate plan late in life, or during a serious illness.
  • A new will that benefits one person to the exclusion of close family.
  • The main beneficiary arranging the lawyer, attending the appointment, or remaining in the room.
  • The person becoming dependent on one individual for housing, medication, transport or daily care.
  • Contact with other family members becoming difficult or being cut off.

These are reasons to look more closely, not conclusions. A challenge needs evidence that the person’s own intentions were displaced.

What evidence tends to matter

Coercion rarely happens in front of witnesses, so these cases are usually built from records and timelines rather than from direct testimony about what was said.

Evidence What to collect What it can show
The drafting lawyer’s file Notes, intake records, correspondence, billing entries. Who arranged and attended the meetings, whether the person was seen alone, and what instructions were recorded.
Medical records Hospital and family doctor records, assessments, medication history. Physical or cognitive vulnerability around the time the will was made.
Financial records Bank statements, changes to account ownership, transfers of property. Whether a wider pattern of financial dealings accompanied the change to the will.
Witness accounts Statements from neighbours, care workers, friends and family. Changes in the person’s circumstances, contact with others, and daily life.
Discuss your situation with us

The drafting lawyer’s file is usually the first thing a lawyer will want, and there is a procedure for obtaining it in an estate proceeding. What it records about who was present and what was asked often shapes the rest of the case.

Who has to prove what

The person challenging the will carries the burden of establishing undue influence, on the balance of probabilities. The person benefiting from the will does not have to prove the absence of it.

There is a related principle worth knowing about. Where the circumstances in which a will was prepared or signed raise genuine suspicion, the person putting the will forward may be required to establish that the person making it had capacity and knew and approved its contents. That is a separate question from undue influence, and the two are often argued alongside each other.

Lifetime gifts are treated differently from wills in this area, which is one reason a transfer made before death may be analyzed differently from the will itself.

Deadlines, and the practical reason to move early

Deadlines for challenging a will in Ontario are strict, and a claim brought too late can be barred entirely. Our article on how long you have to challenge a will in Ontario sets out how the timing works.

There is a practical reason to act early as well. Once the estate trustee has authority and the estate has been distributed to beneficiaries, recovering those assets becomes considerably harder and more expensive than preventing the distribution in the first place. There is a step available at the court office that requires notice to be given before a certificate of appointment is issued, and it is one of the first things to ask a lawyer about. Our guide on how to contest a will in Ontario covers the overall process.

What happens if a will is set aside

Where a court finds that a will is invalid, it is treated as though it had never been made. The estate then passes under the most recent valid will, if there is one. If there is none, the estate is distributed under the intestacy rules in the Succession Law Reform Act.

That outcome is worth thinking about before starting. Setting a will aside does not necessarily produce the distribution a challenger has in mind, because what replaces it is a previous will or the statutory rules, not the court’s view of what would be fair. If the concern is that a valid will fails to provide for someone who depended on the deceased, that is a different claim: see being left out of a will in Ontario.

What to do if you suspect undue influence

Evidence in these cases degrades quickly, so the early steps matter.

  • Write down a timeline while details are fresh: when the will changed, who was involved, what changed in the person’s circumstances.
  • List people who saw the person regularly, including care workers and neighbours.
  • Preserve emails, messages and any financial records you already have access to.
  • Find out whether a certificate of appointment has been applied for, because that affects how quickly you need to act.

Speak with an estate litigation lawyer

Powell Litigation represents clients across Ontario in estate litigation, including will challenges, dependant support claims and disputes with estate trustees. If you believe a relative was pressured into changing their estate plan, an early conversation is usually the difference between preserving your options and reacting after the estate has been distributed. Consultations are available in person, by phone and by Zoom. Contact us or call (437) 222-2234.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between persuasion and undue influence?

Persuasion appeals to someone’s reasoning or feelings while leaving the decision to them. Undue influence removes that freedom through coercion, threats or manipulation, so the resulting document reflects someone else’s wishes. Family members asking to be remembered in a will is not, by itself, undue influence.

Can a will be challenged if a caregiver was the main beneficiary?

It can be. A caregiver often occupies a position of trust and control, and where that position was used to isolate or pressure the person, a court can set aside provisions benefiting them. Being a caregiver and a beneficiary is not improper on its own; many people leave something to those who cared for them.

How much does it cost to challenge a will in Ontario?

Costs vary considerably with the complexity of the evidence, the number of parties and whether the matter settles. Our article on what civil litigation costs in Toronto explains how legal fees and disbursements usually work, and a lawyer can give you a realistic assessment for your situation.

What if the drafting lawyer says the deceased acted voluntarily?

That evidence carries weight but is not the end of the matter. The file is examined alongside everything else, including whether the person was seen alone, what was recorded, and what was happening in their life at the time.

Can I stop the estate from being distributed while I investigate?

There is a step available at the court office that requires notice to be given before a certificate of appointment is issued, which prevents the estate from proceeding without your knowledge. It is time-sensitive, so it is worth asking a lawyer about promptly.